open thread on critical realism
Folks at the Chicago ethnography conference (and this blog) were not happy with critical realism. Use this as an opportunity to defend/attack. Or even just to explain it in terms that humans can...
View Articleeconomists and survey skepticism
Over at Evil Twin, Nicolai Foss gently chides Bloom and Van Reenen for publishing a paper in the AER proceedings called “New Approaches to Surveying Organizations.” The issue is the validity of survey...
View Articlekieran healy on the philosophy profession
Our friend Kieran has a series of posts on his research at Leiter Reports, the leading academic philosophy blog. Aside from writing on economic sociology, Kieran has begun an ambitious project...
View Articlethe 2016 presidential race
Over at Salon, Alex Pareene made fun of people who try to guess presidential politics. Fair enough, there are a lot of lame guesses. However, there are patterns. It’s not as hard as you think....
View Articlecode for the add health data set
Michael Bishop, of the Permutations blog, has set up a web site to archive R code for Add Health. Rather than have every Add Health researcher reinvent the wheel, he wants to sponsor an open source...
View Articletwo performativity questions
These questions came up during orgtheory training last week. I did not have good answers: A lot of performativity research focuses on stock options, less on futures. Why? Are there good studies of...
View Articleevent history analysis question
Let’s say you are doing discrete logit event history analysis. You are simply pooling all cases and time periods and just estimating a logit , where Y = failure event. See Yamaguchi’s (1991) book,...
View Articlestupid statistician tricks
Here’s a conversation I’ve had a few times with statisticians: Statistician: ” … and these simulations show how my results work.” Me: “What does your research tell us about a sample of, say, a few...
View Articlea response to andrew gelman on the statistics discipline, but not scott...
On Friday, I write a semi-humorous post about the interaction between statisticians and non-statisticians. The issue that brought it up was that sometimes statisticians like to work on asymptotic...
View Articleethnography is totally generalizable
I’m still mulling over some of the issues raised at the Chicago ethnography and causal inference conference. For example, a lot of ethnographers say “sure, we can’t generalize but ….” The reason they...
View Articlehey, it’s scale free and … and …
A focus of network research since, say 1999 or so, has been to identify “laws” that generate large networks with certain properties.* For example, the small world network is built by rewiring a grid....
View Articleresponse to gelman on retractions in science
Last week, I argued that retractions are good for science. Thomas Basbøll correctly points out that retractions are hard. Nobody wants to retract. Good point, but my argument wasn’t about how easy it...
View Articlestata bleg: text matching
Attention Stata people (esp. Sr. Rossman): Let’s say I have a data base of articles. I have a variable with the author’s name. Then I want to match the author’s name with other data (e.g., Fabio Rojas...
View Articleamerica is not getting lonelier
A key empirical question in social network analysis is whether Americans have more or less friends over time. Famously, Robert Putnam argued that indeed, we were “bowling alone.” In contrast, critics...
View Articleproblems vs. theory
What makes a study interesting? Is it the empirical phenomena that we study or is it the theoretical contribution? For those of who are really paying attention (and I applaud you if you are), you’ll...
View Articleselection bias in surverys – recent developments?
A common problem in social research is selection bias – the people who choose to respond to your survey may be systematically different than the population. We have some methods, like the Heckman...
View Articlecongressional district data bleg
What is the go to source for 2008 or 2010 Congressional district demographic data? A nice table with summary stats for each district would be great. Adverts: From Black Power/Grad Skool Rulz
View Articletake this orgtheory survey!
Jesse Fagan, an orgtheory PhD student, asked that we publicize a pilot study that he’s conducting. He wants to know how orgtheory scholars percieve journals. Please use Firefox or Chrome to complete...
View Articlewhy obama may lose the popular vote in one simple picture
A few days ago, I noted that Obama is slightly behind in the polls mainly because of the South. If it weren’t for the South, Obama would easily have about 51% of the vote in rest of the country. Kieran...
View Article
More Pages to Explore .....